German Court rules about liability for open source software

Back to articles

11 December, 2013

On 29 November, the District Court of Hamburg decided that German software company Appwork is liable for a copyright infringing feature in their open source software project JDownloader2, created by someone else.

Appwork created JDownloader2, a tool to download and extract video files and files from file-hosting sites. The software is an open source project, which means that other developers can add functionalities to it. In June, JDownloader2 became the subject in court proceedings, because of a specific feature in a beta version of the software which enables the downloading of streaming videos. The plug-in was a contribution from an open source developer who had worked on the project before.

The Court of Hamburg decided that the plug-in represented a circumvention of an “effective technological measure” under $95a of the German Copyright Act, thereby constituting a copyright infringement. The Court issued a preliminary injunction against JDownloader2 and banned Appwork from “production, distribution and possession” of the software as long as it allows the illegal downloading of copyright protected material. Appwork filed an appeal, but the Court maintained its view. According to the Court, Appwork should have prevented that the illegal feature in JDownloader2 was offered through by prior checks of the code. Therefore, the company is liable for the copyright infringing code.

Appwork is considering their options for appeal, so there might be a chance that this decicion will be overturned in the future. If this decision will be upheld, it will have major implications for owners of open source projects. They will have to monitor all changes in the software and will have to decide whether they are lawful or not. If they don’t, they risk liability for contributions of third parties.

Sources:, TorrentFreak

Jonathan Toornstra

Legal Consultant

Related blogs

Dutch Supreme Court: home copying levy was too restricted

Today, the Dutch Supreme Court decided that the home copying levy has been applied too restricted...

Read more

Article Newsweek: European Internet Pirates Poised for Victory.

One of the members of the Pirate Party has been elected as a member of the European Parliament. In...

Read more

Like to be emailed about Considerati news?

Then subscribe to the Considerati Newsletter! See our privacy statement.